This form is provided by SAM for the 
Editorial Review Board
SAM ADVANCED MANAGEMENT JOURNAL (AMJ) 
SAM MANAGEMENT IN PRACTICE (MIP)  

REVIEW FORM  

All fields are required for this form to submit properly.

ONLINE ARTICLE REVIEW FORM
Article Number: 
Article Title: 
Do not use periods(.) or comma(,) in the Reviewer field
Reviewer: 
Reviewer Email: 
Reviewing Date: 
 
Please check the appropriate number to describe your assessment regarding each of the following statements.  The numbers refers to: 
(1) strongly disagree, (2) moderately disagree, (3) moderately agree, (4) strongly agree.
 
A.       THE ARTICLE:
 
1          2           3          4          has sufficient amount of practical coverage
1          2           3          4          is theoretically sound
1          2           3          4          is supported by a logical and in-depth analysis
1          2           3          4          reflects awareness of current theory and previous research
1          2           3          4          is innovative
1          2           3          4          is appropriate for the SAM AMJ or SAM MIP audience
1          2           3          4          covers an important topic
1          2           3          4          is timely
B.       THE WRITING STYLE IS:
 
        clear
        concise
        interesting
        grammatically correct

C.       BRIEFLY SUMMARIZE THE KEY IDEAS/CONCLUSIONS THAT CAN BE DRAWN
           FROM THIS ARTICLE

D.       MY OVERALL EVALUATION OF THE ARTICLE IS:

          EXCELLENT        
          GOOD    
          FAIR
          POOR

         THE ARTICLE IS MORE SUITABLE FOR:

          AMJ        
          AND I . . .  
       RECOMMEND IT FOR PUBLICATION IN PRESENT FORM
       RECOMMEND PUBLICATION WITH MODIFICATIONS
       DO NOT RECOMMEND IT FOR PUBLICATION

PLEASE SPECIFY THE REASONS FOR YOUR RECOMMENDATION: 

COMMENTS/SUGGESTED MODIFICATIONS: 

COMMENTS FOR THE EDITOR ONLY: 
(Comments entered in the field below will only be viewed by the AMJ Editor and will not be shared with the author.)

If you have made revisions on the article,  please send a copy  to the following address:

 
Society for Advancement of Management
6300 Ocean Drive, OCNR 330, Unit #5807, Corpus Christi, TX 78412-5807 USA
Fax:(361) 825-2725      Telephone:(361) 825-6045      E-mail: sam@samnational.org
 If for some reason when you submit this form a confirmation page does not appear,
Please Use you BACK Button and review your selections. 
All form fields are required.